There is a mildly inconvenient fact we should establish before discussing love, sex, Tinder, attraction, jealousy, commitment, pornography, ghosting, or why someone you met twice has somehow acquired the ability to ruin your entire Wednesday.
You are an ape.
A sophisticated ape, certainly. You can read novels, calculate compound interest, operate a dishwasher, and spend twenty minutes composing a text message designed to look as though you gave it no thought whatsoever. You can discuss philosophy, worry about your pension, and have strong opinions about the correct temperature for coffee.
But an ape nonetheless.
This is not an insult. Biologically, humans belong to the great apes, alongside chimpanzees, bonobos, gorillas, and orangutans. We are unusual members of the family, having developed language, cumulative culture, extraordinary cooperation, and the ability to build both particle accelerators and dating apps. Still, underneath all that culture sits an organism shaped by a very long evolutionary history.
That matters because evolution does not start over whenever the environment changes.
It modifies what already exists.
The brain inside your skull was not designed from scratch for modern life. It is the current version of an ancient biological system, assembled gradually through countless generations in environments very different from the one surrounding you now. Some of its machinery is extraordinarily old. Some is more recent. All of it arrived before Wi-Fi.
This does not mean that humans are prisoners of instinct. Culture matters enormously. Learning matters. Individual experience matters. People differ from one another in ways that cannot be reduced to a tidy evolutionary story.
But evolution gave culture something to work with.
And one of the things it gave us was a remarkable interest in other people.
Especially certain other people.
Especially when they are attractive.
Especially when they might be attracted to us.
That part has caused trouble for quite some time.
The Problem With Not Being Horny
From an evolutionary perspective, there is something peculiar about every person alive today.
They come from an uninterrupted line of organisms that successfully reproduced.
Not most of the time.
Every single time.
Go back through your parents, their parents, their parents before them, and continue far beyond anything we would recognize as human. At every generation along that enormous chain, at least one ancestor managed to survive long enough and reproduce successfully enough for the chain to continue.
One broken link and you would not be here.
This does not mean every ancestor was a romantic success story. Almost certainly not. Some relationships were loving, some practical, some brief, some coercive, some arranged, some opportunistic, and many occurred in social worlds so different from ours that applying modern dating categories to them would make little sense.
Evolution does not particularly care about candlelight.
It cares, in the most impersonal sense possible, about continuation.
Traits that consistently prevented organisms from reproducing tended to have difficulty traveling very far into the future. Traits that helped organisms survive, attract mates, form useful bonds, care for offspring, or otherwise contribute to reproductive success had more opportunities to persist.
Over immense stretches of time, this helped shape motivational systems that make certain things feel important.
Food feels important because organisms indifferent to obtaining energy had a rather serious disadvantage.
Danger feels important because organisms indifferent to predators often became energy for somebody else.
Social acceptance feels important because humans are deeply social animals whose survival has long depended on other humans.
And sex?
Sex did reasonably well too.
You do not need an evolutionary psychology textbook to discover that humans are unusually preoccupied with attraction, romance, sex, and relationships. Our songs reveal it. Our films reveal it. Our novels reveal it. Our advertisements reveal it. A significant portion of the internet reveals it with considerably less subtlety.
We write poems about people we want.
We lose sleep over people we want.
We change clothes because of people we want.
We join gyms, buy perfume, learn guitar, download apps, rehearse conversations, remove body hair, grow body hair, travel across cities, and occasionally make spectacular fools of ourselves because of people we want.
A truly neutral observer might conclude that something important is happening.
They would be correct.
Attraction Is Not a Character Flaw
This is worth saying because modern discussions about dating often become strangely moral.
Someone wants sex too much.
Someone cares too much about appearance.
Someone is too selective.
Someone is too jealous.
Someone wants commitment.
Someone avoids commitment.
Someone keeps chasing unavailable people and then spends three hours explaining to a friend why this particular unavailable person is different.
There are certainly healthier and less healthy ways to behave. People can hurt one another badly. Desire does not excuse dishonesty, coercion, cruelty, or selfishness. Understanding where an impulse may come from is not the same as approving whatever someone does with it.
But the existence of the impulse itself should not surprise us.
A brain that notices potential partners is doing something brains have had reason to do for a very long time.
A brain that cares whether it is attractive to others is not malfunctioning merely because the concern sometimes becomes uncomfortable.
A brain that dislikes romantic rejection is not being irrational simply because the person doing the rejecting was practically a stranger.
These systems existed before dating apps.
The apps found them waiting.
That distinction will matter throughout this book.
Tinder did not invent sexual desire. Instagram did not invent social comparison. Pornography did not invent sexual curiosity. Read receipts did not invent rejection anxiety, although they did provide it with an impressively precise timestamp.
Modern technologies rarely create human motivation from nothing. More often, they encounter something that already exists and change the environment in which it operates.
Sometimes they amplify it.
Sometimes they redirect it.
Sometimes they make satisfying it easier.
And sometimes, rather inconveniently, they make it easier to stimulate without making it easier to satisfy.
That last distinction is going to become important.
The Brain Does Not Know About Tinder
There is a tempting way to talk about evolutionary mismatch that we should avoid.
It goes something like this:
Our brains were built for the Stone Age. Modern life is unnatural. Therefore everything modern is bad, and we should all throw away our phones, eat roots, and move into a forest.
This is nonsense.
For one thing, there was no single ancestral environment. Human populations lived across changing climates, ecologies, social structures, and subsistence patterns. Our ancestors were adaptable. That adaptability is one of the reasons our species became so successful.
For another, modernity has solved an extraordinary number of problems.
Antibiotics are evolutionarily novel.
So are eyeglasses.
So is anesthesia.
So are supermarkets, sewage systems, weather forecasts, contraception, video calls, and the small machine in your pocket that can summon both a taxi and a photograph of almost any naked body part within seconds.
Novel does not mean bad.
Mismatch is subtler than that.
A mismatch can occur when a trait or motivational system that developed under one set of recurring conditions operates in a substantially different environment. The trait does not suddenly become defective. The relationship between the trait and its surroundings has changed.
Imagine an appetite shaped in environments where concentrated calories were valuable and often difficult to obtain. Put that appetite in a world containing cheap, delicious, energy-dense food available twenty-four hours a day and nothing mysterious has happened to the appetite.
The environment changed around it.
Or take attention. A system that rapidly notices socially important information, threats, novelty, movement, and reward can be extremely useful. Place that same system beside a device containing news, messages, outrage, pornography, games, social status, entertainment, and an effectively endless supply of novelty, and again, the attention system has not necessarily become defective.
It has become extremely employable.
Dating technology presents a similar possibility.
Human attraction developed in social environments where potential partners were real people embedded in real social worlds. They had histories, reputations, relatives, friends, mannerisms, smells, voices, expressions, and relationships with other people you might also know.
A modern dating profile is something different.
Six photographs.
A few sentences.
Age.
Height, sometimes.
Job, perhaps.
A list of interests.
A declaration of love for travel.
Maybe a photograph taken from the top of a mountain to prove it.
From this compressed package, another human being is asked to make a decision.
Left.
Right.
No.
Maybe.
Next.
This is not necessarily worse than meeting someone through friends, at work, in a bar, at church, at university, at a dance, or while arguing over the last available avocado.
It is simply different.
And difference matters when the machinery making the decision is old.
We Did Not Evolve With a Search Function
Consider what a dating app allows you to do.
You can specify an age range.
You can restrict geography.
Depending on the service, you may filter for education, religion, politics, smoking, drinking, height, family plans, relationship goals, or other characteristics.
Then the system begins presenting candidates.
This is astonishing.
Not morally astonishing. Technologically astonishing.
For most of human existence, people could not summon a sortable collection of nearby single humans meeting predetermined criteria. There was no slider for distance. There was no setting marked show me women aged 28–34 within 20 kilometers who want children but do not smoke.
There were just people.
Some available.
Some unavailable.
Some attractive.
Some irritating.
Some related to you, which complicated matters.
Some living far away.
Some already involved with somebody else.
Some who thought you were wonderful.
Some who absolutely did not.
Your romantic market was constrained by geography, social networks, opportunity, culture, family, status, and chance.
Modern dating does not remove all of those constraints, but it loosens several of them dramatically.
That is one of its great achievements.
It is also where our story begins.
Because when the size of the apparent pool changes, the psychology of choosing may change with it.
Suppose you live in a world where there are five realistic potential partners. You may be selective, of course. Humans have always been selective. But every rejection reduces the remaining pool in a way that is difficult to ignore.
Now imagine a world in which rejecting someone produces no visible reduction in opportunity.
Swipe left.
Another face appears.
Swipe left.
Another.
Swipe left.
Another.
The supply seems untouched.
You can reject fifty people and the machine does not begin looking worried.
It simply produces number fifty-one.
This creates a strange psychological environment because the pool can feel much larger than the number of people you could ever realistically meet, date, evaluate, or form relationships with.
The options are real.
But the infinity is partly an illusion.
You have limited time, limited attention, limited emotional energy, and, unless your calendar is considerably more interesting than mine, a limited number of evenings per week.
The app can display people much faster than a human life can contain them.
The pool expanded.
The ape did not.
Choosing Is Expensive
We usually speak about choice as though more must be better.
And up to a point, it often is.
If a town has one restaurant and you hate it, a second restaurant is excellent news. Ten may be even better. More choice can increase the probability that one option suits your needs, and dating is no exception.
A larger dating pool can be enormously valuable.
Someone living in a small community may have few compatible partners nearby. Someone belonging to a sexual minority may benefit enormously from technology that makes compatible people visible to one another. People with specific values, lifestyles, disabilities, religions, interests, or relationship goals can find one another across barriers that once made meeting extremely unlikely.
We should not lose sight of this.
The horny ape has gained genuine powers.
But every power changes the problem.
Once the pool becomes sufficiently large, selecting someone requires rejecting alternatives. The more alternatives we can imagine, the more opportunity cost enters the decision.
A person can be wonderful and still not possess every desirable characteristic.
This is normally obvious.
It becomes less obvious when the alternatives remain visible.
Perhaps your date is warm, intelligent, attractive, and funny, but not particularly adventurous.
Somewhere in the app is someone climbing a mountain.
Your date loves adventure but does not share your taste in music.
Someone in the app has listed your favorite band.
Your date shares your music taste but is two inches shorter than the height you usually prefer.
The app has a height filter.
Your date meets the height requirement but owns a disturbing number of photographs involving fish.
There are limits.
The point is not that standards are foolish. The point is that an enormous visible pool can make imperfections more salient because alternatives are always available for comparison.
Every real person contains trade-offs.
A profile does not have to.
A profile only has to suggest possibility.
And possibility is remarkably difficult to compete with.
Your Brain Is Not Looking for “Objectively Best”
There is another complication.
Attraction is not a spreadsheet.
Humans certainly care about characteristics in potential partners, and researchers have spent decades studying patterns in those preferences. But what people say they want, what attracts them in a photograph, whom they actually choose, how attraction changes after interaction, and whom they eventually build a satisfying relationship with are not necessarily identical questions.
This should not be surprising.
You may have a type until you meet someone who is not your type.
You may believe a particular trait is essential until you fall for someone who lacks it.
You may be intensely attracted to someone who is catastrophically wrong for you.
You may feel almost nothing toward someone who appears perfect on paper.
Human attraction involves bodies, personalities, context, timing, familiarity, reciprocity, social information, individual history, culture, and factors we still do not fully understand.
Then we built a system that asks people to make rapid judgments using a tiny subset of those signals.
Again, this does not make the system bad.
It makes it interesting.
A profile must compress a human being into information another person can evaluate quickly. Inevitably, some characteristics become easier to assess than others.
Appearance is immediate.
Height fits neatly into a number.
Job fits into a line.
Education fits into a category.
Whether someone makes you feel safe after a terrible day does not fit particularly well into a profile field.
Neither does the way they treat a waiter when the restaurant is busy.
Or whether silence with them feels comfortable.
Or whether they can make you laugh when your life has gone sideways.
Or whether, three years from now, they will sit beside you in a hospital waiting room at four in the morning and somehow make the room feel less frightening.
These things take time.
Swiping is fast.
That difference may matter more than we realize.
The Ape Meets the Interface
Dating apps did not merely increase the number of people we can meet.
They also changed the order in which we learn about them.
In ordinary repeated social contact, attraction can emerge from a mixture of signals accumulated over time. You see how someone behaves. You hear them speak. You watch them interact with other people. Familiarity develops. Personality becomes visible. Attraction may increase, decrease, or appear where none existed initially.
A swipe interface has a different job.
It must help you decide whether this person deserves the next few seconds.
That encourages speed.
Speed encourages simplification.
Simplification encourages us to rely on whatever information is easiest to process.
And the easiest information to process is not necessarily the information that best predicts whether two complicated apes will still enjoy eating breakfast together five years later.
This is not Tinder's fault.
Tinder cannot realistically require a twelve-week observational period before allowing you to swipe left.
The interface solves a practical problem.
But every solution creates a structure, and structures influence behavior.
A supermarket changes how we encounter food.
A feed changes how we encounter information.
A dating app changes how we encounter potential partners.
Once we understand that, we can stop asking whether technology is good or bad and ask a more useful question:
What does this particular environment encourage an old human mind to do?
That question will follow us through the rest of this book.
A Very Successful Animal With a Very New Toy
It is easy to laugh at modern dating because, viewed from a sufficient distance, much of it is genuinely funny.
Millions of adult primates photograph themselves, write tiny advertisements describing their personalities, submit those advertisements to strangers, sort one another with their thumbs, experience bursts of excitement when mutually selected, exchange carefully calibrated messages, meet in designated locations, and then return home to discuss the encounter with other primates.
We call this normal because we are inside it.
From outside, it is magnificent.
But the joke should not obscure what is actually happening.
We have taken some of the oldest and most emotionally powerful human motivations and connected them to technologies capable of expanding choice, accelerating judgment, quantifying attention, increasing novelty, and keeping alternatives continuously visible.
That does not doom us.
It does not mean the apps cannot work.
It certainly does not mean we should return to some imaginary golden age of courtship that never existed.
It means we should expect surprises.
The human mating mind is not stupid. Quite the opposite. It is flexible, responsive, socially sophisticated, and capable of navigating enormously complicated relationships.
But flexibility is not the same as immunity to context.
Put a capable mind in a strange enough environment and capable minds can do strange things.
They can spend months looking for love while repeatedly avoiding anyone imperfect enough to actually love.
They can accumulate matches without meeting people.
They can mistake being desired for being connected.
They can keep searching long after searching has stopped serving the goal that started it.
They can become very good at dating.
And strangely bad at leaving the dating market.
None of this happens because humans suddenly became shallow, selfish, commitment-phobic, or incapable of love.
The more interesting possibility is that we built a romantic environment with features our motivational systems had never encountered at this scale before.
More people.
More comparison.
More novelty.
More information.
More rejection.
More validation.
More possibility.
The ape did what it has always done.
It adapted.
Just perhaps not always in the direction we expected.
In the next chapter, we are going to shrink the dating market again. Dramatically.
No apps. No algorithms. No filters. No profiles. No endless queue of attractive strangers waiting behind the current one.
Just a human social world with edges.
Because before we can understand what abundance changed, we need to understand what it replaced.
And there was one feature of the old mating market that modern dating has become exceptionally good at removing.
Eventually, you ran out of people.